Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Michele Bachmann, cervical cancer's BFF



Michele Bachmann is still defending her opposition to the vaccine that prevents HPV, the leading cause of cervical cancer. At a campaign event in Sheldon, Iowa on Monday night, she sympathized with a mother who believes her daughter Jessica, now 16, has been debilitated by headaches, pains and seizures brought on by the vaccine three years ago and can no longer attend school.

"Michele, on behalf of myself and a lot of other mothers that have a child that’s sick from the Gardasil vaccine, I would like to thank you for the attention that you brought to it," Julie Wepple said, according to the Des Moines Register.

Bachmann thanked Wepple for bringing up the vaccine issue. "Parents have to make that decision for their kids because it isn't the schools that are going to follow up with Jessica," she said. "It isn’t the schools that live with Jessica every day. It’s Jessica who’s having to have her body live with the ravages of this vaccine."

I sympathize with Ms. Wepple, but... please. This is all Bachmannesque conspiracy theory. Here's what I wrote after Bachmann raised the issue back in September:

After the debate, she sent out "a fundraising appeal," as the WaPo reports, claiming that the HPV vaccine, already opposed on the right for supposedly promoting promiscuity, can lead to "mental retardation." There is good reason to call out Perry, who mandated the vaccine in Texas, for his connections to the vaccine's maker, the pharmaceutical giant Merck, but Bachmann's claim is completely unfounded, just the sort of claim you can expect from a rampant conspiracy theorist like her. Even if you're suspicious of Big Pharma (as I am), even if you think that some vaccines are unnecessary and possibly worse (as I do, though I'm hardly anti-pharma and consider most vaccines to be essential to good health), it takes a leap into the chasm of craziness to think that this particular vaccine, Gardisil, causes "mental retardation." There may be side effects, of course, as there are with all drugs, but Gardisil would appear to be safe. My conservative friend Ed Morrissey acknowledges this, and Dear Leader Rush actually said that Bachmann had jumped the shark (as if this was finally the last straw).

Of course in Bachmann's view, there is no shark.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Immigration racism and vaccine conspiracies: What we learned about Michele Bachmann during and after Monday's GOP debate


It's been over for Michele Bachmann for some time. Once Rick Perry jumped into the race, there was no room for her on the right as Mitt Romney's main conservative rival. And that was that. With her poll numbers tanking, with the writing on the wall, with key staff stepping down, the dream was over.

Just last month, I could write that Bachmann was "crazy, extreme, formidable." She was on top of the world -- or at least the Republican presidential world.

She's still crazy and extreme, but now she's anything but formidable. Things can change quickly in politics.

And yet she fights on -- and, as she does so, we learn that she's even crazier and more extreme than we thought:

1) During the debate, she claimed that "[i]he immigration system in the United States worked very, very well up until the mid-1960s when liberal members of Congress changed the immigration laws." Actually, that system was deeply discriminatory, as Think Progress notes. Immigration laws passed in 1924, including the National Origins Act and the Asian Exclusion Act, established "a quota system giving preferential treatment to European immigrants," as "the practical effect of these laws was an enormous thumb on the scale encouraging white immigration." This was changed in 1965 with the passage of the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965, "an act which is widely credited for opening up our nation to new Americans of Asian and Central and South American descent." In other words, Bachmann was advocating an immigration system that excluded non-whites. This is also known as racism.

2) After the debate, she sent out "a fundraising appeal," as the WaPo reports, claiming that the HPV vaccine, already opposed on the right for supposedly promoting promiscuity, can lead to "mental retardation." There is good reason to call out Perry, who mandated the vaccine in Texas, for his connections to the vaccine's maker, the pharmaceutical giant Merck, but Bachmann's claim is completely unfounded, just the sort of claim you can expect from a rampant conspiracy theorist like her. Even if you're suspicious of Big Pharma (as I am), even if you think that some vaccines are unnecessary and possibly worse (as I do, though I'm hardly anti-pharma and consider most vaccines to be essential to good health), it takes a leap into the chasm of craziness to think that this particular vaccine, Gardisil, causes "mental retardation." There may be side effects, of course, as there are with all drugs, but Gardisil would appear to be safe. My conservative friend Ed Morrissey acknowledges this, and Dear Leader Rush actually said that Bachmann had jumped the shark (as if this was finally the last straw).

Like I said, she's done. But she's not going quietly, and I suspect that we can expect more of this craziness as she tries desperately to remain relevant.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

The conservative lies about health-care reform just keep coming and coming


You know what, if conservatives really think the health-care reform package currently in Congress is sooooo bad, and sooooo unpopular with the American people, they should just shut the fuck up and let it pass so that Democrats suffer at the polls for having passed it. Isn't that what they want?

But their ongoing and increasingly desperate opposition to it suggests that they actually know better, or maybe just that there's this nagging fear that, once passed, the sausage-making done, the very popular details of reform in the open at long last, health-care reform will actually be not just hugely successful as policy, historical change to an unjust, unfair, and costly system, but hugely beneficial to the Democrats in the long run, including perhaps in November.

But you know what, I've had it. Conservatives should just shut the fuck up, period. All they are is a bunch of bullshitting obstructionists who have no interest whatsoever in meaningful reform of any kind. Pajamas Media, for example, is touting a new poll conducted by the Center for Medicine in the Public Interest that purports to show that popular opposition to the reform legislation is overwhelming. Well, PJM is a right-wing website and the CMPI is a front for the pharmaceutical industry. Should we really take this poll seriously?

First of all, the poll is loaded with bias. Take the following:

Six in ten Americans (60%) agree that a current Democrat proposal to send the Senate health care bill to the president without voting up or down on it is "unfair."

It's Democratic, not "Democrat." The use of "Democrat" is a sure sign of partisan bias. As for the result, are we really to believe that the American people understand the nuances of parliamentary procedure, including reconciliation and "deem and pass"? Or how about this: Is is unfair that Republicans used the filibuster to block a straight up-or-down vote in the Senate, where reform passed with a supermajority of 60 votes?

Eight Americans in ten (81%) oppose allowing the government to decide what kind of health care coverage Americans are able to purchase.

Yeah, but this isn't in the legislation, and one is talking about having the government control health care, and for individual choice to be done away with. In fact, Obamacare is all about choice, better choices for more people. It's market-oriented reform that would expand choice, providing coverage to many of the uninsured and freeing many who have poor or limited coverage from being denied treatment and from being locked into a system that takes their money and provides inadequate care in return.

Most Americans (87%) oppose having a government panel recommend or decide what medical procedures or medical advances your doctor or health plan can or cannot use.

This is the mythical "death panel" that conservatives like Sarah Palin have been propagandizing about. There would be no such death panels under Obamacare. Conservatives seem to have moved away from the death panel argument, but apparently the lie lives on in polls conducted by the CMPI.

Anyway, it goes on and on like this. It's like asking respondents if they oppose suffering from acute diarrhea and finding that 98% do. Well, obviously. Obviously people object to death panels and being told what care they can get or what coverage they can have. But, then, this whole poll is about making shit up. Obamacare only looks bad, in this poll, because the questions are dishonest.

The president of CMPI, Dr. Robert Goldberg, concludes:

The poll suggests that Americans oppose how the health care bill is being passed and want more debate and a more democratic approach.

Uh, no, that's what Republicans want. And if you want "a more democratic approach," how about a president who was democratically elected supporting legislation that was passed by a supermajority of senators, after a majority of representatives passed an earlier and more robust bill? In the Senate, reconciliation is actually quite democratic, as it would allow a simple majority of senators to pass "patches" to the bill. In the House, "deem and pass" to approve the Senate bill and patches may not be quite as democratic as an up-or-down vote, but let's not forget that the House has already passed a reform bill.

But the lies keep coming, from Republicans on Capitol Hill and Fox News to conservatives in the media and throughout the blogosphere to the Tea Party extremists wielding their fear and venom across the land to the pharmaceutical industry masquerading as an independent health-care organization supposedly dedicated to the "public interest."

They should all shut the fuck up, as they continue to have nothing but poison to contribute to a process that, hopefully, will soon be over with the Democrats passing historic reform legislation.

Labels: , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Friday, January 09, 2009

Conyers contra Gupta

By Michael J.W. Stickings

Needless to say, I'm not alone in my opposition to Sanjay Gupta for surgeon general (though it is evident that it is hardly Obama's most controversial move thus far, generating comparatively little criticism).

As HuffPo reports, Rep. John Conyers has sent a letter to his Democratic colleagues arguing against Gupta:

I join in opposition with respected Noble Peace Prize award wining economist Paul Krugman, who has very serious concerns with having Dr. Gupta be the nation's Surgeon General. [...]

Also, there are highly experienced medical professionals who question whether Dr. Gupta has the necessary experience or even the medical background to be in charge of some 6,000 physicians or more who work in the United States Public Health Service. Gerard M. Farrel, Executive Director of the Commissioned Officers Association, stated in the January 7, 2008 Washington Post that Dr. Gupta will certainly face a "credibility gap" because he never served in the National Health Service Corp, and furthermore, does not have the "experience or qualifications to be the leader of the nation's public health service." Clearly, it is not in the best interests of the nation to have someone like this who lacks the requisite experience needed to oversee the federal agency that provides crucial health care assistance to some of the poorest and most underserved communities in America.

I do not oppose Gupta because he lacks experience -- indeed, what is needed in the position is not so much bureaucratic competence as the ability to lead public relations efforts on public health issues, and, in this sense, Gupta, with his extensive experience in broadcasting, could do well -- but rather because of his flacking for the pharmaceutical industry, that is, because he is part of the problem, a celebrity cog in the marketing machine for Big Pharma and the very system that so badly needs to be overhauled or, preferably, replaced.

Still, Conyers makes a good point, adding to the growing case against Gupta.

Labels: , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Thursday, January 08, 2009

Sanjay Gupta, Big Pharma flack

By Michael J.W. Stickings

I'm still not sold on Sanjay Gupta for surgeon general. In fact, the more I think about it, the more I dislike the very idea of putting Gupta in charge of public health.

As I wrote on Tuesday, when the story broke, Dr. Gupta "seems to be very much a part of, as well as a defender of, the status quo, namely, the corporatized health care system controlled by Big Pharma and the HMOs."

And, indeed, more is coming out about his seemingly unethical (or at least questionable) dealings. For example, at TNR's The Plank today, Marin Cogan and Suzy Khimm add that he is "no stranger to the ethically sticky situation physicians often find themselves in with drug companies":

For over six years, Gupta has been co-hosting "AccentHealth" -- a CNN television segment beamed straight into doctors' waiting rooms, sponsored in part by many of the major pharmaceutical companies. Touted on its website as an "integrated marketing opportunity" that allows companies to deliver their message "in a trusted environment," the show has been underwritten by drug industry leaders Aventis, Pfizer, Procter & Gamble, Merck, and Warner Lambert.

At the same time, Gupta has been appearing on CNN's primary broadcasts as an ostensibly objective medical authority, discussing the drugs produced by the very same pharmaceutical companies.

In other words, Gupta takes money from Big Pharma and then promotes their products both directly to patients and more broadly (and untransparently) in his capacity as a celebrity doctor on television. And he has done this, no doubt much to his profit, for drugs like Lipitor (cholesterol), Aventis (allergies), and Gardasil (HPV).

I realize that the world of health care ethics, not least where Big Pharma is concerned, is rather murky. The fact is, like it or not, these companies, and others like them, do manufacture and market drugs that work -- and that we would not want to do without. I do not necessarily fault them for wanting to sell their products, and to target both practitioners and patients. I would not want a doctor to prescribe a drug simply because he or she accepts what he or she is told unthinkingly, but if a doctor, like Gupta, thinks a drug is effective, then he or she should be able to speak positively to it.

As Cogan and Khimm point out, though, "[a] growing body of evidence... suggests American medicine is far too aggressive, which leads to higher costs and, all too frequently, actual harm for patients. If Obama wants to reform the health care system, his surgeon general will have to push back against both the pharmaceutical companies that promote ineffective treatments and the doctors who prescribe them."

The problem is that Big Pharma and the HMOs control health care in the U.S. -- and many doctors just buy into the marketing machine. Gupta may not be your basic GP -- he is surely more aware of the big picture than most -- but what he is instead is a significant contributor to the problem, a telegenic broadcaster with the credibility that comes from being on television. It would be one thing if he simply reported on the pharmaceutical industry and its products from a perspective of balanced detachment. But he doesn't. He actively tries to sell those products, and, in so doing -- and without being open about his connections to Big Pharma -- he's part of the marketing machine at the core of the problem.

Gupta has a lot going for him -- not least that he's an engaging communicator. But surely there is someone else -- a public health advocate, a leading researcher, an expert from the CDC -- who is qualified for the job and who hasn't been shilling for, and profiting off, Big Pharma. At the very least, if his nomination does go forward, Gupta should be required to answer for what he has been doing.

Labels: , ,

Bookmark and Share

Friday, December 26, 2008

Pharmacist to the world

By Creature

WaPo:

The Afghan chieftain looked older than his 60-odd years, and his bearded face bore the creases of a man burdened with duties as tribal patriarch and husband to four younger women. His visitor, a CIA officer, saw an opportunity, and reached into his bag for a small gift.

Four blue pills. Viagra.

"Take one of these. You'll love it," the officer said. Compliments of Uncle Sam.

The enticement worked. The officer, who described the encounter, returned four days later to an enthusiastic reception. The grinning chief offered up a bonanza of information about Taliban movements and supply routes -- followed by a request for more pills.

Why not send a few cases of Prozac over and just be done with the whole war thing altogether.

(Cross-posted at State of the Day.)

Labels: , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

Looking at African issues

By Carol Gee

Today's post features the continent of Africa. It is and always has been a very important region, often neglected by us here in the United States. Before going further you might want to refresh or renew your knowledge about Africa with this excellent "clickable" Africa Guide map. Much of what follows is not good news. It is news of colonialism and exploitation, of assumptions and imperialism.

Under the radar -- Suzie-Q features this headline that speaks for many of us regarding the current U.S. militarization of Africa via its new Africa Command: "Don't feel like the Lone Ranger. I hadn't heard of AFRICOM either." The second entry, "Rumble in the Jungle: The AFRICOM Boondoggle," is a very good little primer on the structure and personnel in AFRICOM. To quote:

. . . major events that portend disaster in the future can slip by with barely a notice by the media, by Congress, or by the public at large. For example, does one voter in a hundred know that the Department of Defense has quietly activated a new regional military command? Just type in the acronym “AFRICOM” into a search box, and the reader will find a DOD website that presents the new United States Africa Command, in the same boosterish manner that Microsoft rolls out a new operating platform.

The Bush administration is very serious about this military effort in Africa, and here is why. A later headline from Suzie-Q reads "George Bush visits Africa to promote the US Africa Command." To quote the quote:

Prof. Horace Campbell Pambazuka News, Fe. 14, 2008 . . . looks at Bush’s visit as an attempt to further militarize the continent and consolidate US holding.

. . . One year after the announcement that he United States government was going to accelerate the militarization of Africa, President George Bush is embarking on a journey to Africa to coerce African societies to align themselves with the neo-conservative agenda of the present US administration. President George Bush will visit five African countries between February 15 -21. The countries are Benin, Ghana, Liberia, Rwanda and Tanzania. George Bush is a lame-duck President who cannot visit real global players so this visit to Africa is an effort to shore up the credentials of the neo-liberal forces in Africa while promoting the conservative ideas of abstinence as the basis of the fight against the HIV –AIDS pandemic.

U.S. military website AFRICOM United States Africa Command. General William E. Ward, Commander. The lead story (or propaganda, if you like) is headlined, "TRANSCRIPT: AFRICOM 'Will Help Africans Deal with African Problems,' Bush Says" To quote:

Command is focused on helping Africans address African problems, not on stationing American troops in or near Africa, President Bush said in a television interview March 19, 2008.

. . . Bush said his administration places high importance on Africa. "First of all, this administration recognizes that Africa is important," Bush said. "That's why we named an African command."

In addition, he said, "hopelessness is the only way radicals can recruit, and therefore we have programs to deal with malaria and HIV/AIDS and hunger. But the other source of instability on the continent of Africa is civil unrest, is civil war, is inflamed passions that break out into violence. And it's in our interests that we help Africans deal with those problems. That's what Africa Command is meant to do. And so it fits into the broader scope of things, the broader war on terror, and also is a -- it's a commitment that we care about the people on the continent of Africa."

There are many objections -- These two and several others in this piece are courtesy of "betmo," my blog friend: AlterNet writes, "US Militarizing Africa (Again)" on 3/2/08, and the Black Agenda Report features "Demilitarize Africa." These also came in via "betmo" from the Common Dreams newsletter (2/25/08) -- "Military plan for Africa panned."

"Keep our Military Out of Africa" from After Downing St.org - HT to "betmo." It is linked to "Resist Africom," where you can sign up as an activist. The Granny Peace Brigade organization will be holding a "teach-in on Afrcom" on March 30.

It is all about the oil -- Bluebloggin says, "Maybe you missed it." The official line of the administration is supporting democracy, combating terrorism and HIV-AIDs, etc. It is not that simple, in my opinion. Just as in Iraq, it is about assured energy supplies. Quote:

Ghana has Oil reserves at 3 billion barrels

We all know why Bush is trying to mend fences in AfricOil. Funny, he finds Africans are suspicious of US Military presence. OK, so military bases aren’t happening, it was a bullshit idea, anyway. Thats what we say in Texas. Bush did not mention the military presence already in Africa. While he is on the Continent he had to address the ongoing genocides. Because the parts of Africa that really need his attention are so dangerous, he sent Condi instead.

Alternative to Middle East oil resources -- A special report from the Boston Globe, "Oil In Africa" is a good basic primer with several articles on the subject, including: "Burdens of oil weigh on Nigerians," and "Oil wealth helping few of Angola's poor."

Corporate exploitation vs. genuine assistance -- The following story could stand for a whole host of Africa's natural resources. It happens to be about farming. And it sounds like the U.S. AID is in on the deal. "Trade-Uganda: Privitisation of Seeds Moving Apace," from IPS News - 2/21/08. To quote:

The Ugandan parliament will soon have a hearing on the draft Plant Variety Protection Bill, . . . likely to entrench the rights of breeders and companies while curtailing the rights of small farmers to exchange, save and breed new varieties using hybrid seeds. . . companies including the likes of Monsanto have been lobbying the government for such intellectual property protection.

They are doing all they can to capture the local market. Government research institutions such as the National Agricultural Research Organisation (NARO), which used to produce traditional seeds for farmers, are now being paid by seed companies to produce their hybrid seeds.

There have been concerted efforts from certain quarters to promote the use of hybrid seeds in Uganda. Early last year, a grant of 150 million dollars was provided to the country and its neighbours by the Rockefeller Foundation and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation to launch the Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa (AGRA). The money is to pay for more research into hybrid seeds, the provision of inorganic fertilizers, water management and extension services to facilitate the propagation of these seeds.

According to the government source, the US Agency for International Development’s project, known as the Uganda Agricultural Productivity Enhancement Program (APEP), has also been actively advocating the adoption of stronger intellectual property rules, including the use of biotechnology.

"Private Security Contractors Look to Africa for Recruits." Until the international security firm, SOC-SMG was thrown out of Namibia for violating their anti-mercenary laws, many caught in a 35% unemployment situation signed up as fighter private contractors. Some experts estimate that there are 4,000 South Africans fighting in Iraq. The story is from the Christian Science Monitor (1/8/08). To quote:

Over the past few years, in Namibia and Uganda, Mozambique, and Burundi, and scores of other impoverished, war-torn countries, American private security companies have increased efforts to hire former fighters for work in Iraq, Afghanistan, and other global hot spots, according to researchers, human rights activists, and those in the private security industry.

. . . But Nangolo and other human rights activists believe this new trend is exploitative as well as destabilizing in a region that is trying to move beyond its violent past.

. . . Since the end of apartheid, which left a number of highly trained, white South African fighters without military work, small private armies have operated regularly across Africa. They've helped government soldiers combat rebels in Sierra Leone, fought against Angolan rebels for control of oil fields, and have been accused of smuggling arms throughout the continent.

Pharma was also on the corporate exploitation list -- "The True Story of How Multinational Drug Companies Took Liberties with African Lives" is a story published on 9/26/05 by Common Dreams in its newsletter. To quote:

The pharmaceutical industry is bracing itself for criticism when the film 'The Constant Gardener' opens next month. But Jeremy Laurance reports that away from the Hollywood script is a true story of how multinational drug companies took liberties with African lives with devastating consequences.

. . . Nobody knows what caused Anas' pain but suspicion has fallen on Big Pharma. Six years earlier, Anas was a patient in a trial of a new drug run by one of the world's biggest companies. A known side effect of the drug, called Trovan, was joint pain. The issues raised by Anas' story have become the subject of a major British film.

There are things citizens can do to get involves on behalf of Africa, such as "Resist AFRICOM" above. I got this note from one.com. It says, "We did it!" The organization reports that it got commitments from the presidential candidates to visit Africa. That is a good way to conclude this post. There will be a new dawn in African/U.S. relations, just as there will be a welcome sunrise in Iraq.

(Cross-posted at South by Southwest.)

Labels: , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Monday, February 18, 2008

In what universe is this true?

By Carl

As you may know, or not, depending on how wrapped up you've been in the election, President Dumbya is in Africa. You may even recall that, back in 2002, Bush made note in his State of the Union address that America would increase its aid to Africa because, as he stated at an international summit later that year, "We fight against poverty because hope is an answer to terror."

In fairness to Bush, he did increase aid substantially to Africa. The trouble is, as measured against GDP,
US aid is still lagging far behind other nations around the globe.

Too, much of that aid was tied to two evil underpinnings: first, that sexual abstinence be the main way of preventing AIDS (enforced by the insistence that no money go to organizations that were working with sex-trade workers), and second, that African nations tighten their patent laws, so that
big pharma companies would have more protections and could charge higher prices for their drugs.

And yet, he had the nerve to say
this to the BBC:

I've got a firm, heartfelt commitment to the continent of Africa and have ever since I became president.

It is to laugh. Given his lack of commitment exhibited to any person of color who hasn't either married into or been adopted by his family, one has to ponder the possibility that Bush is utterly ignorant of what "commitment" truly means.

Africa is in dire straits, Mr. President. It is in dire need of food, medicine, shelter. It is mostly in dire need of water, not just for drinking, but for irrigation.

Most of all, sir, Africa is in dire need of security. Just a quick perusal of the headlines today will demonstrate this:

-- Kenyan militia strike back

--
Uganda peace talks to resume

--
Intervene in Nigeria, Bush urged

--
UN troops 'trapped' in Eritrea

--
Chad declares state of emergency

And that's not even counting the continuing tragedy in Darfur and the Sudan. Sure,
malaria is an huge problem in Africa, but what moron would try to control nature when men themselves cannot be controlled with the current attitude of world leaders, one of willful ignorance?

"Freedom" is just another word for these people, Mr. Bush, and you had an opportunity in the wake of September 11 to do real good in the world, to make America a truly shining beacon of hope and democracy, of security and independence.

Instead, you bullied the world and your own people onto the edge of a cliff.

(Cross-posted to
Simply Left Behind.)

Labels: , , , ,

Bookmark and Share