By Mustang Bobby
Paul Krugman writes that the Republicans have dusted off an old argument
from years ago to block the agenda of President Obama and the
Democrats. Instead of arguing the merits of, say, expanding Medicaid to
people who need it, they now say that giving people a guarantee that
they will have health insurance is an assault on freedom:
Conservatives love, for example, to quote from
a stirring speech Reagan gave in 1961, in which he warned of a grim
future unless patriots took a stand. (Liz Cheney used it in a Wall Street Journal op-ed article
just a few days ago.) "If you and I don't do this," Reagan declared, "then you and I may well spend our sunset years telling our children and
our children's children what it once was like in America when men were
free." What you might not guess
from the lofty language is that "this" — the heroic act Reagan was
calling on his listeners to perform — was a concerted effort to block
the enactment of Medicare.
These days, conservatives make very similar arguments against Obamacare. For example, Senator Ron Johnson
of Wisconsin has called it the "greatest assault on freedom in our
lifetime." And this kind of rhetoric matters, because when it comes to
the main obstacle now remaining to more or less universal health
coverage — the reluctance of Republican governors to allow the Medicaid
expansion that is a key part of reform — it's pretty much all the right
has.
They trot out this pony for lots of other
things, too. Universal background checks and liability insurance for
gun owners shreds the Second Amendment. Giving free or reduced lunches
to impoverished children takes away the parents' rights to feed their
children the way they see fit. Banning interracial marriage is an
assault on the rights of states to protect their own traditions, and of
course the one we've been hearing a lot of recently, permitting marriage
equality is a blatant attempt to muzzle the freedom of the "religious"
to bully and harass the LGBT community.
David Brooks' column
last week where he said that granting gays more freedom actually meant
less was a caricature of the argument, and this is how we know that
they're getting down to the fumes. When they have to tell you that more
is actually less and up is actually down; that more choice for more
people is tyranny and that finding a way to stop a madman from sweeping a
kindergarten with 154 bullets in less than five minutes is the last
step before Stalinism, it makes you wonder at what point will it dawn on
them how utterly contemptuous of freedom they really are.
Labels: Affordable Care Act, David Brooks, freedom, gun control, Liz Cheney, Medicaid, Medicare, Obamacare, Paul Krugman, Ron Johnson, Ronald Reagan