Thursday, February 11, 2010

Earthshattering?

By Carl

I don't think so...

Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has said his country has produced its first batch of uranium enriched to 20%.

[...] Western powers fear Iran is heading towards enriching uranium to 90% - to produce a nuclear weapon. Iran says its nuclear programme is peaceful.

Previously, Iran had enriched uranium to 3.5%, which is sufficient for power needs. 20% is necessary, they claim, for medical isotope purposes, which costs them the grand total of
$1 million dollars a year.

Interesting, the facility most likely to have been used to create the enriched uranium was provided to Iran by the
United States back in 1967 under the "Atoms For Peace" program.

Isn't it ironic, dontcha think?

Previously, Iran had promised a
stunning "punch" to the West. This was more like a feint. Few take the claim very seriously, except of course the fainting-couch denizens.

Scroll down to the comments, if you'd like a good laugh. Or cry. Or laughiecry....

Meanwhile, the truly distressing development in Iran is the government response to the
current wave of protests from dissidents. They have been lining the streets with militiamen, which has kept violence to a minimum.

But there has been
violence.

Curious thing about Iran: for a dictatorial nation, they do seem to be fairly liberal in their policies with respect to dissent. Not as tolerant as the average Western nation, to be sure, but considering what Saddam Hussein used to do, it speaks volumes.

The Obama administration response
has been measured, and if anything, has faulted to the side of caution.

(Cross-posted to Simply Left Behind.)

Labels: , ,

Bookmark and Share

Monday, October 05, 2009

Ahmadinejad... not Jewish

By Michael J.W. Stickings

So it seems, according to this apparently well-researched piece in The Guardian, that Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadmaninejad may not be descended from Jews after all.

So much for the mouth-watering speculation. So much for the possibility, given the man's blistering bigotry, of a ridiculously massive amount of self-loathing, as much as anyone in history has ever exhibited.

Oh well. It was fun while it lasted.

Labels: ,

Bookmark and Share

Monday, June 22, 2009

The latest from Iran

By Michael J.W. Stickings

The protests continue on the streets of Tehran, and elsewhere. And while the clerical powers-that-be, Khamenei et al., have declared Ahmadinejad the clear winner, it is clearer than ever that there were voting or vote-counting irregularities, with the Guardian Council admitting that in some places the number of votes counted exceeded the number of voters. The spokesman for the Council stated that this 100%+ irregularity "happened in only 50 cities," far less a total than the 80-170 alleged by opposition candidates. But, seriously, "only 50 cities"? Are we to take that as proof of Iran's democratic credibility? Is such vote fraud in "only 50 cities" really not that big a problem?

**********

The WaPo reports that "a tense calm" prevails on the streets of Tehran. But the Khamenei-Ahmadinejad regime, now on the defensive, and so going on the offensive, has ratched up its post-election campaign against Mousavi:

Government media lashed out Sunday at Mousavi, suggesting that some of his actions were illegal and blaming "terrorists" for Saturday's violence, in which at least 100 people were injured. The semiofficial Fars News Agency, which has strong ties to the government of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, quoted a law professor at Tehran University as saying that Mousavi's actions were criminal.

"Through uncivil and illegal means, he created an environment for unrest and hooliganism," Firouz Aslani told Fars News. "Contrary to his claims of lawfulness, he acted against the security of the nation and the interests of the system."

Some analysts in Tehran said those comments and others carried in the state-run news media questioning the legality of Mousavi's actions could be the government's way of preparing the ground for his arrest.

Of course. And how predictable. The regime is turning the full weight of the state apparatus on its opponents -- and on the leading opponent in particular. (If you can't beat 'em, in a free and fair election, rig the election, and if that doesn't work, or if the rigging is too obvious, arrest 'em or kill 'em.) It obviously perceives Mousavi, as well as the brave men and women who are standing up to it, and demanding change, as a serious threat to its ongoing rule. And the best way to undercut Mousavi's appeal, at least from the regime's perspective, is to brand him not just a dangerous criminal but a traitor to the nation.

It's just not clear to me how vilifying Mousavi benefits the regime. He is the one with the credibility, after all, and the regime would only look that much more transparently oppressive, and illegitimate, were it to arrest its leading opponent. Are Iranians really so gullible that they would accept the regime's claim that Mousavi is a criminal and traitor?

**********

The NYT is reporting that Iran's ruling clerics are deeply divided.

The regime has arrested five of former President Rafsanjani's relatives. Rafsanjani is pro-Mousavi. His relatives were released.

**********

The BBC is reporting that people were killed during Saturday's protests.

Mousavi is claiming that there have been "mass arrests."

State TV is calling the protesters "terrorist groups."

**********

REMEMBER NEDA.

Labels: , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Sunday, June 21, 2009

So they are one now?

By MSS

As I have noted at various times over the last two and a half years of occasional analysis of Iranian elections and other developments, it has been clear that the Supreme Leader and the incumbent President are not exactly allies. There have even been signs that each might be trying to use the various elected and non-elected institutions established in the wake of the Islamic revolution to get rid of, or clip the powers of, the other.

However, it seems even more clear that in recent days, in reaction (and that is certainly the correct word here) to the protests against the suspicious 'reelection' of the president that the Supreme Leader has thrown his fate in with that of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

Yesterday, the Supreme Leader's attempt to appear above the fray, as a mediator among the clerics' factions, evidently collapsed, when opposition candidates Mir Hossein Mousavi and Mehdi Karroubi declined to attend what was hailed as a reconciliation meeting (seen at Juan Cole, but his link to the story no longer works).

The Iranian regime, with its odd combination of a narrow self-appointed ruling clique of clerics and relatively open (albeit restricted) elections, could regulate the significant divisions within the elite via elections so long as the electorate accepted the limited choices offered and the official results. Obviously, that equilibrium (if it can said ever to have been one) has now broken. As I noted a few days ago, it is rare for an authoritarian regime to tolerate the defeat of an incumbent president in elections and yet remain authoritarian. It seems as though the Supreme Leader himself understands that basic political-science fact, and probably has all along.

Now, mostly likely, either the 'supreme leader' and 'president' (inverted commas now because clearly their legitimacy is gone) either go out together (in which case Iran has a chance to become a democracy) or they stay (in which case the Islamic Republic survives, but in a much narrower and more openly authoritarian form). I have to agree with Gershon Shafir that the latter is more likely now. However, writing at the same site, Augustus Norton is not so sure that the forces of repression can maintain the upper hand, if protests continue, and given the continued open divisions within the broader clergy.

How this might end is still uncertain, and may remain so for a time. But a solution within the framework of the Islamic Republic as we have known it looks increasingly out of reach.

Cross-posted at Fruits & Votes.

Labels: , ,

Bookmark and Share

Monday, June 15, 2009

Iran

By Creature

I've been following the news closely, but I really don't have much to add. I am heartened to see that Khamenei has called for a probe of the election results. While the results of such a probe will most likely be in Ahmadinejad's favor, at a minimum, it shows that the clerics are nervous about the sustained and growing demonstrations and probably hints at fissures within Iran's Guardian Council. The genie is out of the bottle.

Labels: , ,

Bookmark and Share

How Ahmadinejad is like Bush/Cheney/Rove

By Michael J.W. Stickings

I haven't blogged on it, but I've been following the Iranian election, and post-election, closely -- and it's pretty clear that Iranian democracy is a sham.

Here's Andrew Sullivan, bringing it home with some of the best analysis I've read (making a point that is sure to freak out the right):

Ahmadinejad's bag of tricks is eerily like that of Karl Rove - the constant use of fear, the exploitation of religion, the demonization of liberals, the deployment of Potemkin symbolism like Sarah Palin...

Think of this regime as Cheney and Rove in a police state setting, and you see what's been going on. (Of course, Rove and Cheney live within a democratic system utterly unlike Iran, and there's no evidence they would violate democratic norms as Khamenei just did. But their demagoguery, abuse of the state, dedication to conflict abroad, co-optation of the armed forces, and manipulation of rural and religious voters all have parallels in Red State Iran.) We keep expecting to see some kind of shame or some attempt at rational dialogue. They have nothing but contempt for that kind of talk. If they're going to lie, it's gonna be a Big Lie. Like this sham of an election.

And, of course, of course, no one -- neither Andrew nor I (nor anyone else I can think of) is suggesting that Bush, Cheney, and Rove are as bad as Ahmadinejad. They're not Holocaust deniers, after all, nor have they suggested that Israel ought to be wiped off the face of the earth. But in some ways -- that is, in terms of their democratic activity (i.e., running for election) -- the similarities are striking.

We are right to applaud the brave protesters on the streets of Tehran, and elsewhere. We are right to demand the release of opposition figures, critics of the anti-liberal, anti-democratic Ahmadinejad regime (although it is Ayatollah Ali Khamenei who runs the show, of course). We are right to call on President Obama to speak out in support of Mir Hossein Mousavi and the courageous opposition (as Republican Rep. Mike Pence has done -- I applaud him, for perhaps the first time, though I disagree with his criticism of the Obama Administration for what he calls an "olive branch-and-apology approach to enemies" (as if Obama is any worse than Bush on that front! as if that hasn't been American policy generally!)). We are right to be suspicious of the outpouring of support for Ahmadinejad. And we are right to remember that Iran is not a democracy, however vibrant its culture, but a police state, and that the Iranian people are subjected to appalling oppression.

But we are also right to remember that American democracy, while better and healthier than Iran's "democracy," isn't perfect either.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Friday, June 12, 2009

Iran: Mousavi claims he won the presidency

By MSS

Via Reuters:

Former prime minister Mirhossein Mousavi said he was the "definite winner" in Iran's presidential election on Friday against President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.


Iran's president is elected by two-round majority. There are other candidates, so a runoff could be required, as it was four years ago when Ahmadinejad was elected to his first term.

One of the other candidates is Mehdi Karroubi, who narrowly missed the 2005 runoff, being edged by Ahmadinejad by less than two percentage points. Ahmadinejad in 2005 won only 20.3% of the vote in the first round, to 22% for former president Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani. Ahmadinejad won the runoff 63.4-36.6.

Of course, Iran is by no means a democracy, and the presidency controls the interior ministry, which is responsible for the administration of elections. So official election results have to be taken with caution. Still, it is a lot easier to steal a close election, such as 2005, when Ahmadinejad's second-place finish in the first round was considered a "surprise," and Karroubi alleged fraud. In this election, we are unlikely to see a surprise second-round contender, as we did in 2005 (if a runoff is even needed this time). However, if results show Ahmadinejad narrowly ahead, we can expect suspicions to be rife--especially considering the "unprecedented" turnout. Iran may not be a democracy, but there is a lot of interest in this election.

The interest extends to expatriates, who are eligible to vote. This surprised me, as I would have imagined that expatriates would be more likely to be opponents of the regime, and denied voting rights for that reason.

At Fruits & Votes (to which this is cross-posted), I have previously discussed Iran's unusual brew of authoritarianism with quite competitive elections.

Labels: , ,

Bookmark and Share

Monday, March 09, 2009

Around the World: Darfur/Sudan, the United Kingdom, France, Iran, and Turkey

By Michael J.W. Stickings

Here's our latest ATW round-up -- all very interesting stories, make sure to check them out:

1) Darfur/Sudan: Darfur's Justice and Equality Movement (JEM), the leading anti-government rebel group, is taking the fight directly to Khartoum. JEM is supported by Chad and is now much stronger than it was just a few years ago.

"If the international community fail to act... we will go to Khartoum and topple the regime ourselves -- we are quite capable of that,” said Ahmed Hussein, a spokesman for the group and a member of its Executive Leadership Office. I realize that there is a lot of blame to go around in Darfur and Sudan, and that JEM is not without its faults, but it is hard not to support any effort that seeks to bring down the thugocracy of President Omar al-Bashir.

2) United Kingdom: A group called the Real IRA has claimed responsibility for the recent attack on Britain's Massereene military base. Two soldiers were killed in the attack: "The soldiers are the first to be murdered in Northern Ireland since Lance Bombardier Stephen Restorick was killed by an IRA sniper in 1997."

In response, Prime Minister Gordon Brown had this to say: "I think the whole country is shocked and outraged at the evil and cowardly attacks on soldiers serving their country. We will do everything in our power to make sure that Northern Ireland is safe and secure and I assure you we will bring these murderers to justice. No murderer will be able to derail a peace process that has the support of the great majority of Northern Ireland." Like Blair, Brown can sound a lot like Bush in his depiction of the world as the struggle between good and evil. Regardless, he is right to stand firm against such terrorism.

3) France: Oenophiles of the world unite! In Givry, a small village in Burgundy, just south of Dijon, residents are fighting back against a new industrial waste facility that threatens their centuries-old traditions, not to mention their famous wine.

"The source of the Givry winemakers' outrage, which has driven them into the courts, is a small problem in terms of the number of people it affects. The population in the village, where the church steeple is still the tallest structure around, is 3,600. But it is part of a broader struggle throughout France, the struggle to balance tradition and modernization, that goes deep into the country's soul and is proving more challenging as the years go by." I don't know much about the specifics, but my inclination, in this case, is to side with the old against the new.

4) Iran: President Mahmoud Ahmad(man)inejad has apparently been the target of a shoe-throwing attack in the Iranian city of Urmia. He deserves far worse.

Meanwhile, Iran has tested a new missile. I have long been in support of high-level diplomacy with between the U.S. and Iran, and I generally reject the warmongering rhetoric of the neocons and their ilk, but Iran is evidently asking for trouble with its military posturing.

5) Turkey: The Turks are still in denial over the Armenian genocide, to the extent that they know anything about it at all. It is state policy to deny, deny, deny -- and, where possible, not to mention it at all. But there are positive signs that the truth is spreading. Make sure to read this, especially if you don't know much about what happened.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Friday, February 13, 2009

"Ah, so these are the intertubes Ted Stevens was talking about? Where can I get Facebook? Death to Israel!"

By Michael J.W. Stickings

Actually, this is Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad at an Iranian nuclear facility. (Michael Crowley posted the photo at The Plank.)

The Los Angeles Times reported yesterday that "the Obama administration has made it clear that it believes there is no question that Tehran is seeking the bomb." Iran now has about 6,000 centrifuges enriching uranium, and it may soon "have enough low-enriched uranium to be able to quickly convert it to weapons-grade material."

All the more reason for direct talks between Washington and Tehran -- and soon.

Labels: , ,

Bookmark and Share

Tuesday, February 03, 2009

It's only arrogance if you're wrong

By Carl

Today's news seems to be themed. Let's scan it quickly, shall we?

1) He will not Blago
gently into that good night:

Former Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich is lashing out at lawmakers who booted him from office, calling his removal a "hijacking."

2) Christian Bale's
F-bombing:

"I want you off the f***ing set, you pr***," Bale reportedly says at the start of the audio recording, which TMZ reported was sent by the film's executives to their insurance company in case the actor didn't finish filming the movie.

"I'm sorry," Hurlbut reportedly replies.

"No, don't just be sorry. Think for one f***king second," Bale reportedly shouts. "What the f*** are you doing? Are you a professional or not?"

The man said to be Bale appears to grow angrier as Hurlbut replies to him in a calm tone, "Yes, I am."

"No, no. Am I gonna f***ing rip your lights down in the middle of the scene? Then why the f***are you walking right through, 'Duh-duh-duh-duh-duh,' in the background," the man said to be Bale, sing-songs. "What the f*** is it with you? What the f*** don’t you understand?"

3) Iran in Space:

For the Iranian government, it is an important milestone along the road to reclaiming Persia's ancient claim to major power status, which it feels the jealous west is trying to deny it.

It is also enormously significant in Iranian internal politics. President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad got elected promising economic benefits for the common man and modernisation. He has made a complete mess of the first part of that mission. Delivering the second is important for his prospects of re-election in June, in the eyes of both the average voter and – even more importantly, given the controlled nature of Iranian democracy – the supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.

All of these items have one thing in common: central to the event is a sense of entitlement, of hubris. Of arrogance.

I know a little something about that.

We've all had our "Bale moments." We've flipped off the driver who cut in front of us, or swerved around someone in the supermarket to beat them to the express line and then argued with them when they raise the mildest objections.

We've all had our "Blago moments," too, trying to defend the indefensible with outlandish comments and thin-skinned objections.

And we've all had our "Ahmadinejad moments," where we try to recapture past glories in an attempt to re-establish ourselves as players in a game. In this instance, Iran is trying to raise the spectre of the old Persian civilization, one that was on the cutting edge of technology and knowledge, centuries ago. Who among us hasn't played a game of basketball years after our sneakers have been put away?

All of these (less so in the case of Iran) are pretty laughable, but mostly because the folks involved are wrong, and wrong for the wrong reasons.

Blagojevich wasn't impeached and removed from office for criminal convictions. He abused the power of his office, something that's fairly clear from even the minuscule evidence that was presented in the Illinois legislature. His objection that he wasn't allowed to present a defense has some merit, to be sure, but from what he's said about the witnesses, it seems he was determined to practice his defense against any criminal charges Patrick Fitzgerald was going to bring. That was a waste of time.

Similarly, Iran doesn't really need to send up a satellite to prove it is ready to lead once again in advancing knowledge. A simple and truly free, secular election would go a long way to proving that, an election not controlled by a fear-ridden Assembly of Experts, grasping to keep power against the samizdats of information the Iranian people have been accumulating.

And Bale, for whatever reason, didn't need to tear into the DP who made a simple yet ugly mistake. Having been in a similar situation myself, you turn it into a blooper reel, let the guy get his job done, and move on. Let the director handle any fall out. Keeping in mind that a few days after this incident, he was arrested in London for assault, it seems likely there's a deeper motive for this outburst.

Arrogance can take many forms: the arrogance of a president who pretends to know everything he needs to know before committing to war, or the arrogance of a driver who claims a parking spot as his own, even though there's already someone waiting for it. The president might be right, he might be wrong. If he's wrong, it's arrogance, hubris. If events prove him right, then he's a leader, a genius.

It's a thin line that separates arrogance from genius. Again, a line I've straddled often. In no way do I intend to defend the arrogance I've noted above, but I'm proud to be considered arrogant, because it means I'm willing to step up and give things a try, and not sit on the sidelines cheering other people on, and following like a sheep. And I'll succeed much more often than not, which is why I keep trying to forge ahead.

It's really only arrogance when you fail epically and you don't learn from it. If you can't balance the humility of having been thrown out of office or dealing with your problems yourself rather than taking them out on others, or surrendering to the notion that perhaps your best days lie ahead, not behind, then you truly are arrogant.

(Cross-posted at Simply Left Behind.)

Labels: , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Tuesday, September 09, 2008

Kidnapping Mahmoud

By Michael J.W. Stickings

An Israeli cabinet minister (and former Mossad agent), Rafi Eitan, has floated the possibility of kidnapping Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and bringing him to trial for war crimes in The Hague. "[A]ll options are open in terms of how he should be brought," said Eitan, who, while with Mossad, helped kidnap Adolf Eichmann.

Ahmadinejad has made threats against Israel, but he hasn't exactly committed war crimes. He's no Eichmann. What's more, unlike Eichmann, he is the (democratic) leader of a sovereign state. As much as we may not like him -- and I don't -- I'm not so sure kidnapping democratic leaders of sovereign states is such a great idea, and the kidnapping of Ahmadinejad would set an awfully dangerous precedent.

It should go without saying that there are much better ways of dealing with Iran and its seemingly crazy leader -- who, however, seems to say incendiary things more for rabble-rousing domestic consumption than for the rest of the world as statements of official Iranian policy -- but unfortunately there are people like Eitan who are all-too-serious about pursuing "all options," no matter the costs and consequences.

Labels: , ,

Bookmark and Share

Thursday, May 29, 2008

The backpedal begins

By Carl

I'm not sure who is in charge of "message" in the Obama campaign, but
this smacks of silliness:

WASHINGTON — With his experience and leadership credentials under sharp criticism, Senator Barack Obama and his advisers are trying to clarify what has emerged as a central tenet of his proposed foreign policy: a willingness to meet leaders of enemy nations.

In an interview on Wednesday, Mr. Obama, of Illinois, sought to emphasize, as he and his aides have done continually over the last few days, the difference between avoiding preconditions for talks with nations like Iran and Syria, and granting them automatic discussions at the presidential level.

While Mr. Obama has said he would depart from the Bush administration policy of refusing to meet with certain nations unless they meet preconditions, he has also said he would reserve the right to choose which leaders he would meet, should he choose to meet with them at all.

Let me get this straight: after six months of chiding from Clinton, Edwards, Biden, Dodd, Richardson, and now, John McCain, someone in Barack Obama's campaign finally woke up at 2 AM a couple of nights ago, slapped his forehead and said "HOLY SHIT! "NO PRECONDITIONS"???? WHAT ARE WE, IDIOTS?"

Now, "no preconditions" means "no preconditions," unless you are putting preconditions on the word "preconditions". Sort of like, "Depends on what your definition of 'is', is."

Apparently, it didn't really mean "no preconditions".

This is a rookie campaign being run by highly inexperienced operatives, and I can almost bet that by Denver (if not, after), Obama will be asked to make some serious changes to his senior staffing.

Or, to put it in flip flop terms, he was FOR appeasing Iran BEFORE he was against it:

This week, Mr. Obama said that he was still considering meeting with Iranian leaders, though he would not necessarily guarantee a direct meeting with Mr. Ahmadinejad.

“There is no reason why we would necessarily meet with Ahmadinejad before we know that he is actually in power,” Mr. Obama told reporters. “He is not the most powerful person in Iran.”

Last week, Mr. Obama offered a similarly nuanced explanation about meeting with President Raúl Castro of Cuba, saying he would do so only “at a time and place of my choosing.”

The caveats belie the simple answer Mr. Obama gave during a debate last summer, when the issue was first raised in a major public forum. Without hesitation or qualification, Mr. Obama said he would hold direct talks with America’s enemies, drawing strong and immediate criticism from his rival for the Democratic presidential nomination, Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton of New York.

“Would you be willing to meet separately, without precondition, during the first year of your administration, in Washington or anywhere else, with the leaders of Iran, Syria, Venezuela, Cuba and North Korea in order to bridge the gap that divides our countries?” asked Stephen Sixta, a video producer who submitted the question for the CNN/YouTube Democratic debate.

Mr. Obama, the first candidate to respond, answered, “I would.”

Several aides immediately thought it was a mistake and sought to dial back his answer. But on a conference call the morning after the debate, Mr. Obama told his advisers that he had meant what he said and thought the answer crystallized how he differed from his rivals.

“I think that it is an example of how stunted our foreign policy debates have become over the last eight years that this is an issue that political opponents try to seize on,” Mr. Obama said in an interview on Wednesday. “It is actually a pretty conventional view of how diplomacy should work traditionally that has fallen into disrepute in Republican circles and in Washington.”

Even after Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton called his position naïve, Mr. Obama refused to shy away from it, at times speaking explicitly in terms of a potential meeting with Mr. Ahmadinejad.

In other words, it would give Ahmadinejad a lot more credibility with the world community than it would with the US government and would do more for Iran than it would do for America, which is an awful way to go about diplomacy, which has long been defined as the art of letting someone get your way.

Now, at no time during this or any subsequent debate or Q&A on this point has Obama ever amended this statement: attack the conventional way of diplomacy and "no preconditions" to meeting world leaders.

So apparently, Senator Obama has come to his senses and joined the "reality based" community of conventional realpolitik!

Now if only the Democratic Party would come to its senses...

(Cross-posted to
Simply Left Behind.)

Labels: , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Thursday, May 15, 2008

Appease porridge hot, appease porridge cold...

By Carl

Not sure I understand
Bush's point here:

JERUSALEM (Reuters) - U.S. President George W. Bush on Thursday decried his critics' calls for negotiations with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad as comparable to the appeasement of Adolf Hitler before World War Two.

Bush's comment in a speech to Israel's parliament appeared to be a swipe at Democratic presidential frontrunner Barack Obama, who has advocated meeting leaders of traditional U.S. foes such as Iran and Cuba without preconditions.

It also followed a visit to the Middle East by former President Jimmy Carter in which he met Hamas leaders, who are shunned by Israel and Washingtion, and urged efforts to draw the militant group into the Israeli-Palestinian peace process.

[...]Bush, who has refused any contact with Ahmadinejad, said the Iranian president "dreams of returning the Middle East to the Middle Ages and calls for Israel to be wiped off the map", and lumped him together in an anti-Israel camp with Hamas, Hezbollah and Osama bin Laden.

"Some seem to believe that we should negotiate with terrorists and radicals, as if some ingenious argument will persuade them they have been wrong all along. We have heard this foolish delusion before," Bush said.

I'm not sure I've heard Obama say that, necessarily, or anyone on the left. I know I don't think that's a good idea, either.

But....

What IS a good idea is what President Bill Clinton -- you remember the guy, brightest President to sit in the White House since Jefferson, greatest President of all time, husband of candidate Hillary Clinton and someone Barack Obama has gone out of his way to paint with strokes of hatred and jealousy? -- did during his tenure: reach out to Iranians moderates and try to establish a dialogue regarding what THEY want.

It's true, Ahmadinejad would probably leap at the chance to have face time with a President Obama, but it's not very likely that would amount to anything, unless it was preceded by many rounds of talks among lower level operatives and with opposition leaders in Iran, such as they are.

Remember, despite Ahmadinejad's posturing, Iran is a fairly moderate country with an educated population, a decent economy, and more important, some freedoms that other Muslim nations do not have.

To suggest that even the rookie Senator from Illinois would be foolhardy enough to justify Ahmadinejad's posturing in the face of that populace belies a deep disregard for the intellectual curiousity of both Iranians and Americans: we'd see through that in a heartbeat. Look what happened when Ahmadinejad spoke at Columbia.

The comparisons to Nazi Germany are a bit outre as well. Germany was controlled by Hitler. Ahmadinejad can't take a dump without the religious council ratifying it. And there's where the talking with Iran might bear some fruit. Mohammad Khatami and Akbar Rafsanjani, pragmatic reformers who have some sway with the council would be valuable players here.

Bush, thankfully, has rendered himself irrelevant prematurely. My suspicion is, someone in his administration watched
The West Wing and tried to arrange a graceful exit for him like Jeb Bartlett's, and creating relevancy for the lamest of ducks in recent memory.

(Cross-posted to
Simply Left Behind.)

Labels: , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Monday, March 31, 2008

Proving a point

By Carl

There's a curious dynamic involved in
this story, one I haven't fully contemplated yet:

Iraqis returned to the streets of Baghdad after a curfew was lifted and the southern port city of Basra appeared quiet on Monday, a day after the Shiite cleric Moktada al-Sadr called for his followers to stop fighting and in turn demanded concessions from Iraq’s government.

Mr. Sadr’s statement, released Sunday afternoon, came at the end of six days in which his Mahdi Army militia had held off an American-supported Iraqi assault on Basra.

OK, the most obvious bit of information we can glean from this story is that al-Sadr is establishing that he is firmly in control of the Shi'ite faction in Iraq. Is this a prelude to his taking over the parliament? Or worse? Is this a signal that Sayyid al-Sistani is preparing to rule over Iraq the way Ayatollahs in Iran have for decades, as "Expwert Jurist"?

After all, he's basically turned on, and then turned off, the faucet of violence, keeping American and British troops dancing in the background while he held off allied-armed Iraqi forces to a standstill.

Clearly, he wanted to demonstrate that the nation will dance to his tune.

He also demonstrated the abject impotence of the American-chosen president, Nuri Maliki, who apparently couldn't crush an uprising any more effectively than the American-led Coalition of the Bribed!

There is an allegory about the lion and the fly, which applies to Iraq: In a fight between a lion and a fly, the fly cannot land a killing blow, while the lion cannot fly.

So it goes with Iraq and the insurgency: we are fighting a fight that we cannot win, despite our overwhelming force, and the Shi'ites know this lion cannot fly.

The ironic thing about this is, this was a fight, and still is a fight, that we didn't have to fight. The sponsors behind this fight, the Iranians, are perhaps the most sophisticated democratic government in the area, just behind India. Yes, the Ayatollah in Iran has supreme power, but if you look at society, even Khameni hasn't been able to stifle all dissent, or make women wear the burqa, or...well, you choose the field, and Iran has advanced fairly far in it, comparatively speaking.

That's not to say we should be holding them up as a model of the Middle East we'd like to see, but we could try working with them to bring them into the fold, so to speak.

Ahmadinejad may come off as a fucking loon, but if you carefully look at the ripples that he sends out, there's a very deep logic to his insanity and it is very profitable to Iran and to its peer nations. And I have no doubt that he speaks for the Ayatollah.

(Cross-posted to
Simply Left Behind.)

Labels: , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Friday, February 29, 2008

Pick your crazy: McCain, O'Reilly, Limbaugh, and Ahmadinejad

By Michael J.W. Stickings

Question: Which is the craziest?

a) John McCain claiming that Obama is all about "the past" on Iraq.
b) Bill O'Reilly equating Arianna Huffington with the Nazis and the KKK.
c) Rush Limbaugh defending the "Husseinization" of Obama.
d) Mahmoud Ahmadinejad calling Iran the world's #1 power.

I'll go with b) and d) -- a tie. McCain's claim is just silly, while Limbaugh's defence of the predictable Republican smear is, well, predictably stupid.

**********

Speaking of the "Husseinization" of Obama -- and I wrote the other day about how the Republican Smear Machine (RSM) will portray Obama as a black Muslim terrorist -- one of the bigger and more despicable right-wing bloggers, Pamela of Atlas Shrugs, is already on the bigoted offensive: "My objective is to unearth Obama's relationship to Islam. Islam is a political ideology and it is incompatible with democracy."

Actually, Islam is a religion, a faith, just like Judaism or Christianity. (Yes, she's that ignorant, that bigoted.) Her actual objective is to smear the entirety of the Muslim religion and to argue that Obama is a terrorist, or at least a friend to terrorists.

And given her ignorant, bigoted view of Islam as, in essence, a cult of terrorism, all she needs to do, in her own mind, is to show that Obama has a Muslim friend, or perhaps has just shaken hands with a Muslim.

Pamela is an extremist, yes, but this is what we can expect from the RSM going forward.

**********

There was much ado over Obama and Farrakhan, even though the former publicly rejected and denounced the latter at the Ohio debate the other night, but what about McCain and Hagee? Hagee is the pastor of a San Antonio mega-church, an evangelist -- an extremist, as crazy as they come on America's christianist right. Even the right-wing Catholic League calls him a bigot, if only because he is anti-Catholic as well as anti-Muslim -- yes, he is an equal opportunity bigot.

He is totally insane and, of course, immensely influential. And he supports McCain. And McCain is "very honored" to have his support.

(For more, see Greenwald, Benen, and Amato.)

Let's review: Obama rejects and denounces Farrakhan, but McCain embraces Hagee. And yet the media are all over Obama while giving McCain yet another free pass.

Yes, the media are crazy, too. And, should he win the nomination, Obama will be required to contend not just with the O'Reillys, Limbaughs, and Hagees of the world, but also with a media establishment that seems determined to cut him down -- yes, just as, over the years, including this one, it has cut the Clintons down.

It'll be ugly -- and an enormous challenge for Obama. I am still confident he is up to the task, but it won't be easy, not up against the RSM and its media mouthpieces, not up against the crazies of the right.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Friday, February 08, 2008

"Hi, 17 for Hannah Montana 3-D... We brought our own glasses."

By Michael J.W. Stickings

Who knew? Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the Madman of Tehran... a huge Hannah Montana fan.


(Actually, it's a pic of the day at the Globe: "Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad wears 3-D glasses to see an aerial map as he visits the aerospace industries center of the defence ministry in central Tehran." But maybe that's just what they want us to believe.)

Labels: ,

Bookmark and Share

Thursday, December 20, 2007

Stopping by a Middle East news stand

By Carol Gee

(image: sumeja @ StockXchng)

What is going on in the Middle East these days,
I asked myself. I confess that my ignorance about the region is a few weeks old. As I read to catch up with the latest from Aljazeera, I picked up a thread that ties all the stories together. What I learned is that factions of people are upset that certain people are not where they are supposed to be. Or, occasionally, others are pleased to see strangers where they usually have not been for some time. (All quotes are from Aljazeera):

Turkey and the Kurds -- shooting at each other has gone on for some time now. But the actions of Kurdish separatists, who would like to establish an intact and sovereign Kurdistan, are now being actively challenged by Turkey, with the help of the U.S. These new developments have proved to be a hornet's nest of complications for the United States diplomatic forces, trying to get the Iraqi government factions to reconcile and move forward. The headline says, "Turkish forces launch Iraq raid." To quote:

Some 300 Turkish troops have crossed over into northern Iraq in an overnight operation hunting Kurdish separatist fighters.

Reports on Tuesday said that the troops had already pulled out, but not before their presence overshadowed a surprise visit by the US secretary of state to Kirkuk in Iraq's semi-autonomous Kurdish region.

Condoleezza Rice was snubbed by the president of the Iraqi Kurdistan region in protest against America's apparent helping role in the military action.

. . . Meanwhile, US military commanders and diplomats in Iraq said they did not know Turkey was sending warplanes to bomb in northern Iraq until the jets had already crossed the border.

Americans have been providing Turkey with intelligence to go after Kurdish separatists in northern Iraq.

The Haj in Saudi Arabia and Iran -- a Sunni country and a Shia country were at odds in the recent past. But they have been having more frequent interactions as part of a larger Middle East family of nations. And the President of Iran is now making his own pilgrimage to Mecca in the heart of Saudi Arabia. The headline is, "Ahmadinejad takes part in the Hajj;" and to quote:

Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the president of Iran, joined millions of Muslims on Mount Arafat, east of Mecca, to mark the spiritual high point of the Hajj. He is the first Iranian leader to take part in the annual Muslim pilgrimage. Ahmadinejad is attending the Hajj at the invitation of King Abdullah, the Saudi king.

. . . Last month, Ahmadinejad publicly rebuked King Abdullah for Saudi Arabia's participation in a meeting in the US city of Annapolis aimed at finding peace between Israel and the Palestinians.

But he also became the first president of Iran to attend the end-of-year annual summit of Gulf Arab leaders that was held in Qatar earlier this month.

Israel and Palestine -- continued killing and territorial conflict. Attacks by each side against the other, demands for recognition of rights, incursions into the other's territories, all continue to plague the peace process that has lagged behind for decades. "Hamas leader renews truce offer" is the headline. To quote from the story:

Islamic Jihad, a group much smaller than Hamas, has been responsible for most of the attacks since Hamas seized total control of Gaza last June from forces loyal to Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian president and leader of Fatah party.

"We stand by our original offer for a truce based on reciprocation and an end to attacks by all sides," Ghazi Hamad, a Hamas spokesman, told Al Jazeera in a phone interview.

"Our position has not changed. We are ready to commit to a truce but Israel would also have to simultaneously commit to stopping its raids and assassinations against the Palestinians."

Earlier reports suggested that Ismail Haniya, prime minister of the Gaza-based Hamas government, made a new truce offer through the Israeli media in a telephone conversation with Suleiman al-Shafi, an Israeli journalist.

Palestinians and Israelis -- conflicted over settling Jerusalem. The so-called "two-state solution" still seems very far away. The factions have split into smaller and smaller groups, and small pieces of land are still in dispute. Neither side has been able to step back and see how their rigid stances are perceived by their opponents. Negotiators always seem bound by worries about being seen as not rigid enough by their own constituencies. The story is headlined, "Israel 'examines' new settlement." To quote:

Israel has said it is examining a plan to construct a new Jewish neighbourhood in occupied east Jerusalem, weeks after sparking criticism for expanding another settlement in the city.

. . . Two weeks ago, Israel invited bids for more than 300 new housing units in another settlement at Jebel Abu Ghneim in occupied and annexed east Jerusalem. Har Homa, as the settlement is known to Israelis, is built on land confiscated by Israel.

. . . Palestinians want the eastern part of Jerusalem, which Israel captured from Jordan in 1967 and later annexed, for the capital of a future state.

. . . In its 40 years of control over east Jerusalem, Israel has built new neighbourhoods there that are now home to 180,000 Israelis.

Update: The new headline, just in, reads, "Israel backs off on settlement plan." Good news! Tough choices need to be made by all of these conflicted parties in the Middle East.

The United States is also obliged to make tough choices. As long as our military forces occupy Iraq, the factions will not have incentive to work to reconcile themselves. We need to leave them to it. We need to begin talking to Iran in the process, who can be enlisted in solutions because of potential interest in a peaceful Iraq. And most of all, a strong, concerted and skillful U.S. initiative towards a peaceful settlement between Israel and Palestine will go a long way towards bringing peace to the entire region. The establishment of Palestinians in a contiguous area that can sustain a united population, and a peaceful settlement of Israelis in a secure area to which they have an acknowledged right, is the dreamed-for "two state solution." The U.S. owes such a big effort to the region. Goodness knows we have made such a mess. We really need to clean up after ourselves with more good offices than have been forthcoming so far. All this may have to wait for a new president. The current leopards are probably not going to change their spots.


(Cross-posted at South by Southwest)

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Wednesday, December 05, 2007

Is Dubya the Iranian Candidate?

By Edward Copeland


Could George W. Bush be the Iranian Candidate? Like Mrs. Iselin in The Manchurian Candidate, who spouted anti-communist rhetoric while secretly working for their agenda in the U.S., could Dubya really be an Iranian plant? Can you imagine anyone else who has done as much for Iran than he has?

I originally wrote those words in a tongue-in-cheek post on my blog July 26, 2006. Now, in light of this week's National Intelligence Estimate, I have to wonder if I stumbled upon the truth in my jest.

Think about it. He lumped Iran in with the Axis of Evil just as students and reformers were making strides in that country. Dubya may want to blame everything on Iran's batshit crazy president, but he didn't win election until after the Axis of Evil speech.

Iran was similarly held in check by the buffer of their crazy neighbor next door, Saddam Hussein, but Dubya took him out and turned that country into a chaotic mess where Iran's religious leaders wield influence they never had before.

Over in Lebanon, a fledgling democracy gets cut off at the knees by Iranian-backed Hezbollah who baited Israel into a conflict that set Lebanon back while Dubya stood off to the side, cheering on the fighting as long as he could.

Dubya's lip service to democracy in the region has made radical Islamic elements gain more power in Egypt.

If you want to go way back to the "issue" in question, where did Iran get the nuclear technology it was using to develop both weapons (now apparently abandoned) as well as energy? By the same Pakistani scientist who gave nuke knowledge to North Korea by way of using the ports of the United Arab Emirates, whose deal to gain control of important U.S. ports Dubya tried to save.

Now, with the various U.S. intelligence agencies unanimously deciding that Iran abandoned its nuclear weapons pursuit four years ago, Dubya tries to play dumb and say he had no idea while he pumped up World War III rhetoric. What has happened as a result of this dismantling of what little credibility Dubyaland had? Iran's president, who was growing unpopular in his own country for failing to deliver on campaign promises, has gained in popularity.

I still think Dubya isn't smart enough to cook this up on his own, but he certainly could be a brainwashed dupe. If Dubya is the Iranian Candidate, perhaps Darth Cheney is Mrs. Iselin.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Monday, November 19, 2007

"I'll be there for you / When the rain starts to pour..."

By Michael J.W. Stickings

"Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, left, welcomes his Venezuelan counterpart, Hugo Chavez, to Tehran." (photo: The Globe and Mail)

In case you were wondering, here's part of their conversation:

Hugo: Look, Mahmoud, I can make this coin disappear.

Mahmoud: You are a man of many talents, Hugo. You know what I can make disappear?

Hugo: What's that, my friend?

Mahmoud: Homosexuals. There aren't any in this country. We execute them.

Hugo: Ha-ha. I love your sense of humour. So dry.

Mahmoud: No, Hugo, I'm being serious.

Hugo: Oh, okay. Sure. You know what I'm making disappear in my country?

Mahmoud: Homosexuals?

Hugo: No, no, not them, not so much.

Mahmoud: What then?

Hugo: Democracy!

Mahmoud: Ah! Yes! Very good!

Hugo: I won an election, you know.

Mahmoud: Hey, so did I. We're both democratic.

Hugo: Yes, of course we are! Ha-ha! Democratic revolutionaries!

Mahmoud: Do you ever read those -- oh, what are they called? -- web logs?

Hugo: Blogs? Yes, sometimes.

Mahmoud: I read one, by some guy in Canada, who said you're using salami tactics to seize more and more power. That's how he describes your revolution.

Hugo: Yes, yes. I know that one. La reacción. I hate that blog.

Mahmoud: So do I. He says mean things about me. They're all so mean!

Hugo: They don't like Bush, though.

Mahmoud: Bush, huh. Stupid idiot. But he's good for me. He's turning my people against the West.

Hugo: Same with me, my friend, same with me. Besides, look what he's doing to his country.

Mahmoud: Yes, I respect him, in a way.

Hugo: Yes, I know what you mean. Just don't say that publicly!

Mahmoud: Of course not! Never! Now, off we go, please. Let me tell you about our energy program, the one that has Bush shitting his pants.

Hugo: You're a good man, Mahmoud.

Mahmoud: Thank you, Hugo. It's mutual.

Hugo: Down with America!

Mahmoud: Down with America!

Labels: , , , , ,

Bookmark and Share

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

Breaking News! Bush reaching out to Columbia University's Bollinger with plum position

Believes school president can be asset in sliming war critics, up-front, face-to-face; Cheney wants him for more Iran bashing

By J. Thomas Duffy


It appears that Columbia University Lee Bollinger's 15-minutes in the spotlight yesterday may land him in the White House.


Sources have told The Garlic that the Bush Grindhouse flocked to televisions, as Bollinger, face-to-face, with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad sitting a few feet away, and exorcised his school's invited guest, with blistering, double-barreled shots, including "Let’s, then, be clear at the beginning, Mr. President you exhibit all the signs of a petty and cruel dictator."


So impressed was the Grindhouse staff, that Vice President Dick Cheney, furiously scribbling in the margin of a newspaper, quickly whipped out his cellphone, calling former White House Smearmeister Karl Rove, ordering him to turn on his television and watch Bollinger.


Cheney, according to some of the staffers interviewed, was already making moves to bring Bollinger into his Iran Study Group.


"The President," offered one West Wing staffer who was present, "had tears in his eyes."


A spontaneous burst of applause and shouts erupted when Bollinger hit Ahmadinejad again with;


"For the illiterate and ignorant, this is dangerous propaganda. When you come to a place like this, this makes you, quite simply, ridiculous. You are either brazenly provocative or astonishingly uneducated."


Our sources tell us that Chief of Staff Josh Bolten was the first to suggest bringing in Bollinger for a White House position.

Bolten was overheard saying to The Commander Guy that "he can slime our war critics, face-to-face ... Walk right up the hill and lay into them ... He's got a brass set balls on him ..."

"Boy, does he ...," The Decider Guy was said to respond to Bolten, adding that "he might just take the shine off of Turd Blossom's mantle ..."

And, according to our sources, when Bollinger ended his attack on Ahmadinejad with "I am only a professor, who is also a university president, and today I feel all the weight of the modern civilized world yearning to express the revulsion at what you stand for. I only wish I could do better," Bolten was already on the telephone to Columbia University, making arrangements for Bollinger to come down to Washington.


Reportedly, late into the evening, extra speech writers were ushered into the White House, to begin writing custom, individualized attacks on members of Congress, in preparation of Bollinger coming in and doing a read-through for The Commander Guy.


The White House officially refused comment on the report, and, when asked as she rushed into the White House, Homeland Security Advisor Fran Townsend offered "I didn't know there was a Columbia University."


More as this story develops


















(Cross-posted at The Garlic.)

Labels: , , , ,

Bookmark and Share