What the Iraqi insurgency is all about
Whatever we may think of the Iraq war, and of the American occupation, and however much we may criticize, rightly, the atrocious treatment of some detainees at American detention facilities like Gitmo, it's important to keep in mind just what the other side is doing. We know how brutally Saddam treated Iraqis, but we're finally getting a glimpse of just what the insurgents are like -- see here (it's a tough read, but an important one).
Let us debate the conduct of the war/occupation, but let us also keep in mind that we're all on the same side -- or, at least, we should be. I know it's hard to see that, especially for those of us on the left or in the center who disagree with the Bush Administration and who find much of the zealously pro-war right so repellent, but some perspective is required if we are to deal with Iraq without resorting to blind partisanship.
There will always be those on the extremes who refuse to see things as they are and who approach every issue with a mind to scoring political points, but let us at least try to do the right thing irrespective of the usual left-right divisions that plague American politics. And, for now, in that regard, let no one think that America and Americans are in any way on the same level of inhumanity as those who wage war on their own people and who don't give a damn about human life, whether Saddam or, now, the fascist jihadists who lead the Iraqi insurgency.
Let us debate the conduct of the war/occupation, but let us also keep in mind that we're all on the same side -- or, at least, we should be. I know it's hard to see that, especially for those of us on the left or in the center who disagree with the Bush Administration and who find much of the zealously pro-war right so repellent, but some perspective is required if we are to deal with Iraq without resorting to blind partisanship.
There will always be those on the extremes who refuse to see things as they are and who approach every issue with a mind to scoring political points, but let us at least try to do the right thing irrespective of the usual left-right divisions that plague American politics. And, for now, in that regard, let no one think that America and Americans are in any way on the same level of inhumanity as those who wage war on their own people and who don't give a damn about human life, whether Saddam or, now, the fascist jihadists who lead the Iraqi insurgency.
10 Comments:
There is no doubt that you are correct in your assessment. I have said all along that opposing Bush's policy in Iraq doesn't require that you romanticize the insurgency, which has apparently no interest in anything but destabilizing Iraq. I have seen people on blogs say that the insurgents are really patriotic nationalists, blah, blah, but it seems clear that they are motivated primarily either by Islamist fanaticism or their own power interests.
However, I do think you have to be careful in conflating the insurgents' tactics with the reasons for why the insurgency exists. It's clear to me that a lot of Iraqis support the general goals of the insurgency--ie, getting the US the hell out of Iraq--even if they are appalled by the tactics. It's the same thing as in Viet Nam--as brutal as the VC and North Vietnamese were, they did reflect, to some extent, an element of popular opinion. So, I think you have to be very careful about making a simple equation that the insurgency is anti-Iraqi. In the same way that a lot of Muslims oppose terrorism but a sympathetic to the Al Quaida, I suspect that a lot of Iraqis (certainly the Sunnis) have a general sympathy for the goals of the insurgents. Of course,this may be dissipating as the insurgents' tactics are becoming more and more extreme.
The point is that, as horrible as the insurgents are, we can't deceive ourselves into thinking that the wearinness of Iraqis over the tactics translates into some sort of mandate in support of American policy. We have to be careful not to convince ourselves that the insurgency, by itself, justifies continuing our present course in Iraq. However, I suspect that is what the Bush Administration is doing. No, I am not advocating "cutting and running." What I am doing is saying we have to look at our policy and see if it is succeeding in stabilizing Iraq, instead of the mantra that we "have to stay the course."
By
Marc Schneider, at 11:51 AM
I don't know if I agree, Marc. Observers in Iraq after the fall of Saddam reported that the Kurds and Shiites were fairly elated that he was gone. I don't think they harbor any sympathy for the Sunni/Bathist/foreign fighters that are wrecking havoc in the country. I do think they are upset that America hasn't done a better job protecting them.
It would be better if more Iraqis took an interest in preserving the security of their country, but unfortunately I think too many are hesitant to be active- this is a holdover of the culture of fear perpetuated by Saddam.
A question: if American up and left in the next six months, do you think the suicide bombers would stop? I don't. I think they want to Iraq to return to a Taliban-like state. I think if American left we would soon see a civil war between the three large ethnic groups, exacerbated by Iranians, Syrians, and a bunch of other meddling states. That's my two cents, from an admittedly distant perspective.
As for your post, Michael, I completely agree, and I wish the Democrats could somehow make this sentiment more explicit, if only to marginalize the hard left and sway those on the right alienated by Bush's managing of the war, not the war itself.
By
Nate, at 8:11 PM
Nate,
I'm not saying people aren't glad Saddam is gone--I'm sure they are. But I suspect a lot of them are torn by the way it was done. The fact they are glad to be rid of Saddam doesn't preclude the possibility that the idea of fighting against the American occupiers has some popular support. Obviously, some groups are happy to have us there, especially the Kurds. For the others, though, I think our presence is much more problematic.
My point was that we shouldn't assume that because the insurgency is evil (which it is) that it necessarily means that Iraqis support our presence or our policy. Or that the current policy is the best way to combat the insurgency.
By
Marc Schneider, at 9:41 AM
Oh, absolutely. It doesn't serve much purpose to label the insurgency as "evil". That does nothing to help us understand (and deal with) the situation in Iraq at the moment. Certainly something is terribly wrong with "the current policy". But I think it's important for the left not to fall into the moral equivalency view of things. Democrats in particular need to understand that there's a big difference between being anti-Bush and anti-war.
By
Michael J.W. Stickings, at 1:49 AM
Agreed Michael. There is no moral equivalency. I think the left (by which I really mean the "hard" left) was anxious to annoint the insurgency as an indigenous nationalist movement as it did with the Viet Cong. But the insurgency has nothing to be proud of--once Saddam was out, it would have made more sense to try to help build the new country, which would have gotten the Americans out a hell of a lot faster. But, of course, much of the insurgency had a different agenda.
But my point was that just because, from our point of view the insurgency is irrationally violent doesn't mean that it isn't tapping some popular discontent with the American presence. Pretending that the Iraqis see us as liberators--which they clearly don't for the most part--is just helping to perpetuate the illusion that all we have to do is "stay the course."
By
Marc Schneider, at 9:29 AM
Thanks Best Regards
mirc
mirç
mırc
mırç
mircturk
turkmirc
turkiyemirc
mircturkiye
mirch
mırch
mirc indir
mirc yükle
mirc yukle
mırc indir
mırc yukle
mirc turkiye
turkiye mirc
turk mirc
mirc turk
türkçe mirc
türkce mirc
türkçe mırc
turkce mirc
turkçe mirc
turkçe mırc
turkce mirc
mirc chat
mirc sohbet
mirc ara
muhabbet
chat
blog
muhabbet
forum
forum
turkiyeforum
türk forum
mirc
mircturk
turkmirc
mirc indir
sohbet
chat
bedava sohbet
turksohbet
turkiye sohbet
sohbet odaları
bedava chat
chat odaları
türk chat
türkiye chat
turkada
turkmirc
mirc inndir
karar
By
Anonymous, at 1:20 PM
mirc
mırc
mırç
mircturk
turkmirc
mirc indir
mırc indir
mirç indir
mirc yükle
mırc yükle
mirc yukle
mırc yukle
mirch
mırch
mirc turk
turk mirc
mırc turk
mircada
mircturkiye
muhabbet
mirc sohbet
mırc sohbet
mirc chat
mırc chat
mırc ındır
mirc ındır
türkçe mirc
turkce mirc
turkçe mırc
turkce mırc
By
Anonymous, at 12:53 AM
Thanks so much for this! This is exactly what I was looking for
mirc mırc Türkçe Mirc
turkce mirc mirc indir mirc
mirc indir islami sohbet kelebek kelebek script kelebek sohbet kelebek mirc mirc indir kameralı mirc chat çet cet çet yap görüntülü çet sohbet kanalları kameralı sohbet kanalları
sohbet odaları sohbet odası sohbet odaları sevgili sevgi arkadaş arkadaş ara arkadaş bul arkadaşlık bedava sohbet arkadaşlık sitesi arkadaşlık siteleri partner keyifyap güzel mesajlar oto araba şarkı sözleri biyografi forum astroloji
tarot falı
yemek tarifleri
kameralı sohbet
ikinci el
gazete
gazeteler
günlük gazeteler
erzurum
bedava domain
ücretsiz
benimurl
parça kontör
kontör yükle
sohbet
radyo dinle
radyo mydonose
bedava blog
ücretsiz blog
By
Anonymous, at 6:44 PM
Thanks Best Regards
mirc
mırc
mırç
mircturk
mirctürk
turkmirc
mirc indir
mırc indir
mirç indir
mirc yükle
mırc yükle
mirc yukle
mırc yukle
mirc sohbet
mırc sohbet
mirc chat
mırc ındır
By
Anonymous, at 3:18 PM
Thanks Best Regards
mirc
mırc
mirc indir
mircada
mirc yükle
mircada
mirc
mırc
mirc indir
mirc yükle
forum
sohbet
chat
catlak
kafkas
kafkasya
adige
irc forum
mirc forum
irc forum
mirc forum
irc forum
mirc forum
mirç
mirc inndir
türkçe mirc
By
haydar, at 4:19 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home